Sounds hyperbolic, but I assure you it's not. How many comedies starring women have been released in the last 5, even 10 years? Look at the wide-release comedies of 2010, not counting animated films:
(Note: it's not an official list; I left off some movies that seemed to hover between comedy and drama, like Life as We Know It.)
Youth in Revolt
When in Rome
She's Out of My League
Our Family Wedding
The Bounty Hunter
Diary of a Wimpy Kid
Hot Tub Time Machine
Why Did I Get Married Too
The Back-Up Plan
Sex and the City 2
Get Him To The Greek
Knight and Day
Dinner For Schmucks
The Other Guys
Going the Distance
Love and Other Drugs
How Do You Know
There are some solid female roles in there, to be sure; I loved how real Drew Barrymore and Justin Long's relationship felt in Going the Distance. However, this list is really heavy on romance, and many of the films feature only women paired with men. Are we only interested in women when they are playing wives, mothers or girlfriends? I like romances, but I hate the idea that I can ONLY write romances if I want to write about women. Are we uninterested in female careers, friendships and misadventures? Let's look at the comedies that feature women without a male protagonist or equivalent two-hander male co-star: Sex and the City 2, Easy A, You Again and Morning Glory. SATC2 is largely dismissed as movie that "doesn't count" when it comes to discussion of female-driven comedies because it's based on a huge TV franchise...so that leaves us with three. Three out of 32. How about R-rated female-driven comedies? Just Sex and the City 2. Apparently women swearing or getting raunchy really fucking scares people.
Why? Here's one theory: In 2002, Sony released an R-rated comedy called The Sweetest Thing starring Cameron Diaz and Christina Appelgate. It made a disappointing $9 million in its opening weekend - and when I worked at an agency just two years ago I heard executives continue to use it as an example of how audiences don't like R-rated female comedies. Wha?? It's not as though Land of the Lost's disappointing box office numbers prove that you should never make movies based on TV shows (again, SATC). It seems crazy that one single movie could have such an impact on an entire genre, but for better or worse, that's already happening with Bridesmaids. Actress/writer Jamie Denbo explored the issue in her Huffington Post article "Why Bridesmaids is Important":
But here's why it's actually important to see Bridesmaids. On opening weekend. (Twice if you can afford the admission, time and babysitters). I don't know a female screenwriter, TV writer, actor or comedienne who hasn't heard this statement in the past few months with regards to future projects: "Well, we'll see how Bridesmaids does..."
That sentence means that every creative, brilliant, funny woman in Hollywood is (unfairly) being held hostage to a single film's opening weekend box office. Meaning no studio is likely to take any sort of chance on any new projects perceived to be "female driven comedy" unless they have proof that it can perform. And perform well. (Breathe, Kristen.)
If you support Bridesmaids on opening weekend, you may very well soon have a whole bunch more options to entertain you in the very near future. Because there will be undeniable, financial proof that chicks can be funny to everyone.What this all boils down to is that Hollywood believes - or at least thinks moviegoers believe - that women aren't funny. The Wrap's Sharon Waxman has been blogging on the subject with a series called "Why Women Aren't Funny." First, she disproved the theory via Tina Fey, who wrote in her hilarious memoir Bossypants that sexism has pervaded TV as well as film. In Fey's first week on Saturday Night Live, someone was needed to play Sylvester Stallone's wife - and although Cheri Oteri really wanted the part, "somebody thought it wuold be funnier to put Chris Kattan in a dress," Fey writes. "I remember thinking that was kind of bullshit." Luckily, Fey says that "By the time I left nine years later, that never would have happened. Nobody would have thought for a second that a dude in drag would be funnier than Amy, Maya or Kristen."
Fey says she's adopted Amy Poehler's response to being told what kind of comedy is appropriate for women: "I don't fucking care if you like it." From The Wrap:
This follows a story she recounts when Amy Poehler had a similar reaction to being told that she was the wrong kind of funny. Poehler turned on Jimmy Fallon in the writer’s room of Saturday Night Live when she made a joke that was “dirty and loud and unladylike.”
Fallon told her the joke was “not cute.” Amy, writes Fey, “went black in the eyes for a second, and wheeled around on him. ‘I don’t f----ing care if you like it.’
Poehler is another female who has heroically overcome her gender disability to be unfunny. Fey was not only was a head writer at SNL but now runs and stars in 30 Rock. She has some serious comedy bona fides. In her book she concludes thusly about those (men) who believe that women are inherently not funny:
“Unless one of them is my boss...it’s irrelevant. My hat goes off to them. It is an impressively arrogant move to conclude that just because you don’t like something, it is empirically not good. I don’t like Chinese food, but I don’t write articles trying to prove it doesn’t exist.”Fey and Poehler are proving that comedy and breasts aren't mutually exclusive each week on 30 Rock and Parks and Recreation - a fact that hasn't gone unnoticed by Bridesmaids producer Judd Apatow. "It’s the glory days for female comedy right now,” he told Waxman. “At Saturday Night Live, the women have dominated the show for almost 10 years at this point... I mean, the women who get fired from SNL are brilliant! Seriously!”
Waxman also posed the question to Community creator Dan Harmon, who was challenged by then-NBC president Angela Bromstad to staff his writers' room with half men and half women.
“It’s harder; there are less women looking for work. It’s easier to have an all-white male writing staff,” he said on Tuesday. The reason, he said, is the same for why Hollywood writers room are predominantly white.
“There’s no active discrimination,” he said. “But historically, this is a proactively insular (industry). When I get a pile of scripts, I have to dig extra deep to find funny women. Because there’s a lot more men. I had to find geniuses who happened to be women -- which is harder. You have to read a lot of crap.”Based on my own networking experience and the emails and script notes submissions I receive, it certainly seems that more men are pursuing comedy writing careers than women. Maybe it's because Hollywood keeps trying to tell us that we're not funny?
So tell Hollywood that we are. Go see Bridesmaids. Somehow, the movie's earned an 89% on Rotten Tomatoes, despite the fact that there are a bunch of women in it.